How to Choose the Right Replacement Securities

This content has been reviewed and edited by an Investment Advisor Representative working for Global Predictions, an SEC-registered Investment Advisor.

This is a critical part of smart tax-loss harvesting. You’ve sold an underperforming investment and “booked” a tax loss. Smart move—but what’s next? Picking the right replacement security isn’t just about staying compliant with the Wash Sale Rule. It’s where strategy meets opportunity. With the right choices, you can rebalance, diversify, and set your portfolio on a stronger path.

Let’s break it down, step by step.

What Are Replacement Securities?

Replacement securities are what you might buy after selling an investment to harvest a tax loss. But here’s the thing—it doesn’t have to be just about replacing what’s gone. This is your chance to upgrade, refine, and build a stronger portfolio.

Think of it like this: Every replacement you choose is a step toward aligning your portfolio with where you want to be.

Step 1: Know the Wash Sale Rule (And Avoid It)

If you buy a “substantially identical” security within 30 days of selling at a loss, the IRS won’t allow you to claim that loss as a tax credit.

Hypothetical Violation:
You sell an S&P 500 index fund and buy another fund tracking the same index within 30 days. The IRS generally considers these identical securities, and your tax loss would likely be disallowed.

How to Avoid This:
Choose securities with different holdings, benchmarks, or strategies. (even a small difference is usually fine)

Pro Tip: Tools like PortfolioPilot.com take the guesswork out of finding good replacements, even going as far as scoring similarity between securities.

Step 2: Match Replacements with Your Goals

Avoiding the wash sale rule is important, but it’s not the whole story. The right replacements should push your portfolio closer to your long-term goals.

• For Growth: Sold a tech stock? You could replace it with a broader innovation fund to keep growing while spreading out risk.
• For Income: Replacing a dividend stock? You could look at an alternative stock with similar expected dividend yield in a different industry that better diversifies your portfolio.

Our advice: Think about where you want to go, not just where you’ve been. Every replacement should feel like a step forward.

Step 3: Find a Similar, Not Substantially Identical, Security

When selecting a replacement security, the goal is to maintain exposure to the areas you value while avoiding the IRS Wash Sale Rule. Here's a few things to look for when finding a replacement security:

• Correlation: Look for securities with a similar performance trajectory but slightly different underlying factors.
• Sector or Geographic Exposure: Consider securities in the same sector or region but with a slightly different set of holdings or focus.
• Benchmarks and Indexes: Choose alternatives that track a different, but similar index than the one you sold.
• Asset Class or Security Type: Stay in the same asset class (e.g., stocks, ETFs) but diversify by choosing securities with distinct strategies or compositions.
• Beta and Volatility: Evaluate how the potential replacement aligns with your desired risk level and market responsiveness.

Step 4: Look Beyond Stocks

Who says replacements have to be stocks? Consider exploring bonds, REITs, or commodities to add variety and resilience to your portfolio.

Hypothetical Scenario:
You sell a high-growth tech stock at a loss. Instead of reinvesting in equities, you choose a commodities index fund to keep your high-risk, high-reward portfolio, but increase your overall downside protection.

Here’s why this matters: Different asset classes can act as shock absorbers during market swings, giving your portfolio more overall stability.

Why Replacement Securities Matter

Here’s the bottom line: replacement securities aren’t just a box to check for compliance—they’re a tool to build a better portfolio.

With the right strategy, you can turn tax-loss harvesting into a powerful way to drive long-term growth and resilience.

© 2024 PortfolioPilot.com, Your Personal AI Financial Advisor