What is the Hurdle Rate in Private Equity?

This content has been reviewed and edited by an Investment Advisor Representative working for Global Predictions, an SEC-registered Investment Advisor.

Private equity is often seen as a complex and exclusive investment field, filled with specialized terms like "carried interest," "commitments," and "hurdle rates." Among these, the hurdle rate is a cornerstone concept that every investor should understand. Why? Because it directly affects how profits are shared between investors and fund managers, shaping your potential returns.

This guide breaks down everything you need to know about the hurdle rate: what it is, how it works, and why it’s important for making informed private equity investment decisions.

Key Takeaways

• What It Is: The hurdle rate is the minimum return a private equity fund must achieve before fund managers earn performance fees. Think of it as a baseline protecting investors.
• Why It Matters: It ensures managers are only rewarded for meaningful performance, aligning their incentives with investors' goals.
• How It Works: Often set between 7–10%, the hurdle rate applies after deducting fees. If the rate isn’t met, managers forgo bonuses, keeping investor interests first.
• Types of Hurdle Rates: Soft Hurdle, Hard Hurdle.
• How to Use It: Learn to evaluate funds based on hurdle rates, combined with factors like risk, returns, and manager track records.

Why Should You Understand the Hurdle Rate?

The hurdle rate is more than just a technical term; it’s a critical tool for evaluating private equity funds. Here’s why:

1. Aligning Interests: The hurdle rate ensures fund managers are incentivized to deliver strong performance rather than settle for mediocre returns.
2. Protecting Investors: It acts as a safeguard, ensuring you don’t pay performance fees unless the fund meets a certain return threshold.
3. Guiding Decision-Making: Comparing hurdle rates across funds can help you evaluate risk, potential returns, and whether a fund’s structure aligns with your financial goals.

What is the Hurdle Rate?

In private equity, the hurdle rate is the minimum annual return a fund must achieve before its managers can collect performance fees (often called carried interest). It’s like a performance checkpoint: fund managers only earn bonuses if they deliver returns above this predefined benchmark.

Key Features of the Hurdle Rate

• Expressed as a Percentage: Commonly between 7% and 10%.
• Applies to Net Returns: It’s calculated after deducting management fees and other expenses.
• Linked to Performance Fees: If the hurdle isn’t cleared, managers forgo carried interest, ensuring investors are prioritized.

How Does the Hurdle Rate Work?

To understand the hurdle rate’s impact, let’s walk through a hypothetical scenario:

Hypothetical Example: Calculate the Hurdle Rate Threshold

• Committed Capital: $100 million (total amount invested by investors).
• Hurdle Rate: 8% per year (the minimum annual return the fund must achieve before fund managers can earn performance fees).
• Fund Growth After 5 Years: $120 million (total value of investments after five years).

Step 1: Calculate Hurdle Return

The hurdle rate is compounded annually, meaning the required return grows year over year. To find out the total hurdle threshold after five years, we use the formula for compound interest:

So, for the fund to exceed the hurdle rate, its total value must grow to at least $146.93 million after five years.

Step 2: Evaluate the Fund’s Performance

After five years, the fund grew to $120 million—an overall return of 20% on the original investment. While this may seem like a good return, it falls short of the hurdle rate threshold of $146.93 million.

• Actual Fund Growth: $120 million - $100 million = $20 million (20% return = 3.7% annualized return).
• Required Growth (Hurdle Threshold): $146.93 million - $100 million = $46.93 million (46.93% return).

Because the fund didn’t meet the hurdle rate, managers do not earn carried interest (performance-based compensation).

Step 3: Impact on Investors

Even though the fund didn’t meet the hurdle rate, investors still receive the fund’s total value after five years. This means:

• Total Capital Returned to Investors: $120 million.
• No Performance Fees: Since the hurdle wasn’t cleared, managers don’t take any share of the $20 million profit as carried interest.

Types of Hurdle Rates: What Do They Mean for You?

Private equity funds may use different types of hurdle rates. Knowing these can help you better assess how a fund structures its incentives.

1. Soft Hurdle Rate

• How It Works: In a soft hurdle rate structure, once the fund’s return exceeds the hurdle rate, managers are entitled to carried interest on the entire profit, not just the portion above the hurdle.

Example:

• Hurdle Rate: 8%.
• Fund Return: 12%.

With a soft hurdle rate, carried interest applies to the entire 12% return, not just the 4% above the 8% hurdle.

Why This Happens:

In this structure, the hurdle acts as a threshold to unlock the manager’s eligibility for carried interest but doesn’t restrict fees to just the excess profits.

What This Means for You:

Soft hurdles are less stringent on fund managers and can result in higher fees for investors, even if the returns only slightly exceed the hurdle. For example, even a 0.1% excess over the hurdle (e.g., 8.1%) would entitle managers to carried interest on the full 8.1% profit.

2. Hard Hurdle Rate

• How It Works: In a hard hurdle rate structure, managers earn carried interest only on the profits exceeding the hurdle rate.

Example:

• Hurdle Rate: 8%.
• Fund Return: 12%.

With a hard hurdle rate, carried interest applies only to the 4% return above the 8% hurdle. The first 8% of returns are reserved entirely for investors.

Why This Happens:

The hard hurdle rate ensures that investors receive a guaranteed level of return (the hurdle rate) before managers can participate in the profit-sharing.

What This Means for You:

Hard hurdles are more investor-friendly because carried interest is strictly limited to the profits beyond the hurdle. This means you pay fewer fees if the fund’s performance is only marginally above the hurdle rate.

‍

Why the Hurdle Rate is Crucial for Investors

The hurdle rate protects investors in multiple ways, ensuring that fund managers are rewarded only when they deliver meaningful results.

1. Performance-Based Fees

Investors only pay performance fees if the fund surpasses the hurdle rate, minimizing the risk of paying for underwhelming returns.

2. Incentive Alignment

Managers are motivated to generate strong returns that benefit both parties. This alignment of interests reduces the likelihood of complacency or short-term thinking.

3. Risk Evaluation

Funds with higher hurdle rates often pursue ambitious strategies, offering the potential for greater rewards but also increased risk. Comparing hurdle rates helps you choose a fund that matches your risk tolerance and investment goals.

Hurdle Rates vs. Other Metrics

While the hurdle rate is useful, it shouldn’t be the sole factor in your decision-making. Combine it with other key metrics to get a holistic view of a fund’s performance potential:

1. Internal Rate of Return (IRR): Measures the fund’s overall profitability, considering cash flows over time.
2. Management Fees: Fixed annual fees (usually 1.5–2%) that reduce net returns.
3. Track Record: Evaluate the fund manager’s history of achieving returns above the hurdle rate.

How to Compare Hurdle Rates Across Funds

Different funds set hurdle rates based on their strategies, risk levels, and market conditions. Here’s how to approach comparisons:

1. Assess Your Risk Tolerance

• Lower Hurdle Rates (7%): Indicate a more conservative strategy with lower expected returns.
• Higher Hurdle Rates (10%): Suggest a more aggressive approach, potentially offering higher rewards but with greater risk.

2. Evaluate Manager Experience

• A high hurdle rate paired with an experienced management team is generally a positive sign. Conversely, a high hurdle with an inexperienced team may indicate overconfidence.

3. Align with Your Investment Horizon

• Private equity is a long-term commitment. Make sure the hurdle rate aligns with the time you’re willing to invest and your financial goals.

What Happens If the Hurdle Rate Isn’t Met?

If a fund fails to meet the hurdle rate, managers forgo carried interest entirely. Investors still benefit from the fund’s net returns, minus management fees, but no bonuses are paid to managers.

• Why This Matters: This mechanism ensures that investors aren’t penalized for subpar performance. It also pushes managers to prioritize long-term value creation over short-term gains.

FAQs About the Hurdle Rate

1. Can the hurdle rate change over time?

No, the hurdle rate is typically set during the fund’s formation and outlined in the Limited Partnership Agreement (LPA).

2. Is the hurdle rate always between 7% and 10%?

While these ranges are common, some funds may set rates outside this range based on market conditions or investor agreements.

3. How does inflation impact hurdle rates?

In periods of high inflation, hurdle rates may increase to ensure real returns remain attractive to investors.